← All proceedings

THE IIER INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE

Proceedings cover: THE IIER INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE

Melbourne, Australia 06-01-2022

2 papers

  1. The Refugee in Islamic and International Law: A Comparative and Practical Study on Refugees in Saudi Arabia and Australia

    Mohammed Alsubaih, Abdulrahman Fahim M Alsulami

    Paper ID II-LPSMELB-060122-19007 · Pages 8-11

    Abstract

    This paper employs comparative law to explore similarities and differences in Saudi and Australian Refugee Laws, particularly their compliance with Sharia and Public International Law. The technique of comparative legal research is used to compare various legal norms to analyze refugee laws of both the countries leading to suggestions for changes to strengthen the existing legal jurisprudence and legislation. Comparative study of law from Saudi Arabia and Australia be helpful in providing recommendations for each country to learn from the experience of the other and integrate useful developments in refugee law. The study helps synthesize a comprehensive law to protect the rights of refugees and asylum seekers.

    The researcher has identified and analyzed refugee law from Common law in Australia and examined their application in different court decisions. Additionally, sources of Sharia including Quran, Sunnah, conventions, statutes, has been evaluated in the context of refugee problems. Peter D Cruz’s framework of comparative legal study has been used as a guide for the study to conduct the analysis of legal documents in accordance with doctrinal legal research.

    Qualitative research methodology is used to determine relevant sections of laws, court decisions, and courts’ interpretation of refugee laws in different cases involving asylum seekers. The qualitative approach of reviewing legal documents and literature from Australia and Saudi Arabia through comparative analysis has helped researcher to ascertain the status of refugees and asylum seekers in both the countries. The royal decrees issued by Saudi Arabia are also analyzed for their relevance with Sharia principles protecting the refugee rights. The analysis has been helpful in exploring a common premise from the refugee laws of both Saudi Arabia and Australia and its relevance with Sharia principles and Public International Law.

    Keywords - Asylum seekers, International Law, refugee law, Sharia law, Saudi Arabia law.

    Download PDF
  2. Saudis’ Expectations and Preferences in Relation to Employment Decisions A Vignette Study

    Dalal Alotaibi

    Paper ID II-SSEMELB-060122-18710 · Pages 12

    Abstract

    The study explored the impact of three factors (gender of the job seeker, financial support provided by husband, and type of job and wage) on theSaudi males and females’ expectations about others, in relation to their employment decisions. It also explored males and females’ employment preferences when facing different employment scenarios. The aim of this study is three-fold with respect to social norms: it explores differences between respondents’ expectations about the employment preferences of others, as well as their own; it tests the impact of incentivising work in mixed working environments or low-status jobs by increasing wages; and it tests the impact generated by additional information that contradicts what is considered to be the norm onfemales’ employment decisions. To achieve these goals, 369 Saudi university students were surveyed using an online experimental vignette as a research tool.

    Results showthat all three factors (gender of the job seeker, money provided by the husband, and type of job and wage)have a significant impact on the Saudi males and females’ expectations in relation to employment decisions. Results points to strong pressure that Saudi females are under to follow social norms. This was represented by the high expectations from participants for a female job seeker to choose to work in an SGWE compared to the expectation for a male job seeker, and for a female to be employed only if the husband does not give enough money to secure his wife’s financial needs, and for a female to be employed in a high-status job even with lower wages.

    Furthermore, the majority of Saudi students, males and females, prefer to work in an SGWE and high-status jobs even with lower wages. However, in terms of participants’ expectations in this case, offering higher wages for the mixed gender environment lowered the participants’ expectations for females to choose the SGWE. Thus, monetary incentives (high wages) may have a role to play in changing the perceived social norms related to working in an SGWE. It can be used to increase the acceptance by the society for females to work in a mixed gender environment, which will encourage more females to apply for these types of jobs and therefore increase the levels of female labour force participation in the country.

    Results also have shown that Saudi males and females have assumed that their personal preferences are similar to others or in line with the other participants because they predict that others’ preferences are identical to their preference. This could be a possible justification for their personal preference.

    Results have shown that nearly half of females in the treatment group, compared to females in the control group, have changed their personal preference from working in an SGWE to a mixed gender working environment when they were told that other females’ preferences are different from their own, and that the majority of females prefer to work in a mixed gender environment. Thus, this can be understood as the presence of “pluralistic ignorance” among Saudi females. This shows that those females privately reject the norm (working in an SGWE), suggesting that the given information resulted in changing those females’ perceptions and, therefore, their employment preference. Females’ responses in the treatment group reflect the desire of females to behave and act based on what is considered socially acceptable and desirable.

    Keywords - Preferences, Expectations, Female Employment, Social Norms.

    Download PDF